Passive treatments are less effective for shoulder pain
Evidence to support the use of these treatments is mixed
Shoulder pain is quite common, with one-third of adults experiencing it every year. It ranks fourth behind low back, knee, and neck pain in terms of the most prevalent painful conditions encountered. In many cases, patients with shoulder pain are given a variety of passive physical treatments. Passive treatments don't require the active participation of patients, and some examples include thermal therapy (heat or cold), ultrasound, laser therapy, and shock-wave therapy. Despite the fact that these types of treatments are used regularly, evidence to support their effectiveness is mixed, and some medical professionals don't recommend their use. To better determine if passive physical treatments should be used for shoulder pain, a powerful study called a systematic review was performed on all available literature on the topic.
Five medical databases searched for relevant studies
Five medical databases were searched for relevant studies that evaluated passive physical treatments for shoulder pain. Out of 1,470 articles that were identified, 21 were considered eligible to be reviewed, and 11 of these were found to have a low risk of bias, meaning the quality of their data was high. These studies covered the following passive physical treatments: laser therapy, shock-wave therapy, heat therapy and ultrasound.
Effectiveness of passive physical treatments is called into question
Results from this systematic review were varied, but on the whole, did not support the effectiveness of solely using passive physical treatments for shoulder pain. Laser therapy was found to be more effective than placebo (a treatment that is not intended to have any effect) or ultrasound in the short term for one type of shoulder condition, while shock-wave therapy was more effective than placebo for another type of shoulder pain over one year. Aside from these positive findings, however, the majority of the other treatments evaluated were no more effective than placebos for various other types of shoulder pain when not performed in conjunction with other active therapies. Researchers believe that these findings challenge the role of passive physical treatments used in isolation for shoulder pain, and encourage physical therapists to use treatments that have better support for their effectiveness such as more active-based interventions.
-As reported in the March '15 issue of Physical Therapy
The information in the articles, posts, and newsfeed is intended for informational and educational purposes only and in no way should be taken to be the provision or practice of physical therapy, medical, or professional healthcare advice or services. The information should not be considered complete or exhaustive and should not be used for diagnostic or treatment purposes without first consulting with your physical therapist, occupational therapist, physician or other healthcare provider. The owners of this website accept no responsibility for the misuse of information contained within this website.